Several immigrant business owners are preparing to sue New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani over his proposal for city-owned grocery stores that would sell food at prices up to 30% below traditional retailers. The Multicultural Business Coalition’s board voted this week to pursue legal action against the city, claiming the mayor’s plan to open five taxpayer-funded grocery stores threatens the viability of independent bodegas and competing grocers.
The coalition plans to send a letter to Mamdani’s office within days outlining its legal strategy to protect small businesses. If the mayor does not respond or agree to meet within three weeks, the group will file the lawsuit. Frank Garcia, chairman of the coalition, stated he has sought meetings with city officials for months without success, despite assurances from a city commissioner that engagement with stakeholders would occur. “The commissioner said this administration is open to speak to everybody, and they want to hear from everybody,” Garcia told reporters. “So I’ve been waiting for a meeting for a couple of months. Why aren’t they having me? We are ready to file the lawsuit if the mayor doesn’t meet with us.”
Garcia described the effort as nonpartisan, emphasizing it aims to defend small business owners already struggling with rising costs in New York City. He noted that lawyers will be prepared to file once the three-week window expires and cited support from a coalition of civil rights and community organizations across political affiliations. The Multicultural Business Coalition was formed earlier this year specifically to oppose Mamdani’s grocery store initiative and includes members from African, Asian, Caribbean, Hispanic, Jewish, and Middle Eastern business communities. It has drawn backing from city and state lawmakers, including New York State Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins.
The lawsuit follows renewed criticism of Mamdani’s plan, with opponents branding it a “communist fantasy” and a threat to independent grocers operating on thin margins. The mayor has defended the initiative as a way to lower food costs for residents, but critics question whether government-run retail can undercut private grocers without straining city finances or distorting local markets that bodegas and immigrant-owned stores depend on.