Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr has firmly rejected Disney-owned ABC’s assertion that the agency is engaged in “attempted censorship,” insisting the review of the network’s broadcast licenses stems from evidence of discriminatory hiring practices rather than political motives.
In a 119-page regulatory filing posted Thursday, ABC accused the FCC of sending a chilling message to media companies nationwide by scrutinizing its eight television licenses. The network’s lawyers stated that “the retaliation against ABC is a signal to every media company in the country: accommodate the Administration’s view of what news coverage should look like or pay the price.”
Carr has flatly denied that characterization, stating, “I don’t view the FCC as the speech police.” He clarified that the license review originated from an ongoing investigation into ABC’s diversity, equity and inclusion policies, not a reaction to the network’s news coverage.
During his remarks, Carr detailed the concerns behind the review: “The Disney case is about evidence coming to light, we haven’t made a final decision yet, that they had been discriminating inside the company based on race and gender, in terms of hiring, promoting, compensation, workplace opportunities.” He added, “If that all ends up being true, based on all the evidence that Disney gets to put in, that’s a very concerning development, and it does raise fundamental questions about fitness to have a license.”
An FCC spokesperson reinforced Carr’s position, asserting that broadcasters must serve the public interest rather than “the narrow or partisan interests of a political party” and are barred from discriminatory practices, hoaxes and news distortion. “The FCC is going to hold broadcasters accountable to the full extent of the law, regardless of any disinformation campaign that some of them may choose to run,” the spokesperson said.
ABC’s filing cited over 153,000 public comments and warnings from figures including Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch and Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) about regulatory overreach. Some conservatives and free-market advocates have separately raised concerns regarding granting an appointed federal agency sweeping authority over news content, regardless of which party holds the White House.
Not all conservatives support ABC’s stance. The Center for American Rights, which petitioned the FCC to deny the licenses, urged Thursday that the case proceed to an administrative hearing. “Disney’s lawyers can wish upon a star, but they cannot make this record disappear,” said Daniel Suhr, the group’s president.
The dispute began in April when Carr initiated early license reviews for all eight Disney-owned stations and intensified this month after President Donald Trump publicly urged the FCC to strip both ABC and NBC of their licenses over their handling of a presidential address. ABC has engaged prominent litigators, including former Solicitor General Paul Clement, to challenge the review.