A botched lethal injection attempt has triggered renewed debate over the humanity of capital punishment in the United States, following a second failed execution in Tennessee this year.
Krista Pike, convicted of murdering 19-year-old Colleen Slammer in 1995, was reportedly tied to a stretcher during her execution attempt on September 30. According to reports, she snored loudly and rhythmically for an extended period and exhibited signs of suffocation, indicating she remained alive far longer than anticipated.
The incident occurred after prison staff administered two doses of the lethal injection, but Pike’s condition deteriorated rapidly. She was rushed to the hospital in critical condition, where her lawyer Randy Spivey confirmed she is receiving urgent medical attention. Spivey stated that multiple errors were made during the procedure, noting staff attempted seven punctures on Pike’s left arm alone to establish an intravenous access and observed her right arm turning blue during drug administration.
Corinna Barrett Lane, a law professor at the University of Richmond specializing in U.S. death penalty practices, noted such incidents are not isolated. She cited statistics showing a 7-8% error rate for lethal injections—nearly double that of other execution methods—and warned this figure surged to almost 40% in 2022. “This is the second time it’s happened in Tennessee,” Lane said, adding the state suspended all executions in May after a similar failure. She emphasized the idea of “humane” murder is deeply flawed, referencing autopsy findings that victims often suffocate for one to three hours before death.
Governor Bill Lee ordered an independent review of the execution process following the incident. State authorities have temporarily halted all death sentences until year-end pending the investigation. Pike was scheduled to become Tennessee’s first woman executed in over two centuries. Her defense team has demanded her sentence be overturned and replaced with life imprisonment without parole, citing constitutional protections against cruel and unusual punishment.