Decoy Dan’s Alaska Senate Campaign Triggers Federal Subpoena Surge

The Justice Department has issued more than 200 subpoenas in its criminal investigation of Dan J. Sullivan, known as “Decoy Dan,” who appeared on Alaska’s Senate ballot alongside Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan.

Mary Peltola, a former state lawmaker and the first Alaska Native elected to Congress, won the four-way general election with 144,302 votes compared to 131,844 for incumbent Senator Dan S. Sullivan, 6,105 for Republican Gerald Heikes, and 4,760 for “Decoy Dan.”

Allegations emerged that Democrats sought out a second Sullivan to run as a decoy in an effort to confuse voters and divert support from the Republican candidate. Marc Elias, a prominent Democratic election lawyer representing Peltola’s campaign, received a criminal target letter from the Justice Department earlier this month.

Days before the November 3 midterm election, it was reported that Peltola’s campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and outside political operatives engaged in what they called a “ballot composition project” to recruit a second Sullivan. However, Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC have denied wrongdoing.

The second Sullivan is a retired teacher from Petersburg, a small island town in southeast Alaska. He ran with minimal visibility and raised $35,556 for his campaign. Alaska election officials initially attempted to remove him from the ballot, but the state Supreme Court allowed him to remain. In October, the Justice Department sued to limit what it described as the “misleading” impact of his candidacy.