A coalition of 28 district attorneys has filed a petition asking the California Supreme Court to block Governor Gavin Newsom’s deeply unpopular decision to commute the death sentences of 548 inmates to life in prison without parole.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation (CJLF), a Sacramento-based crime victim advocacy group, organized the lawsuit with support from the California District Attorneys Association, the Peace Officers Research Association of California, and several victims’ advocacy organizations.
Newsom announced on November 5 that he planned to commute every existing death sentence before leaving office, stating that “state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values, undermines the foundations of our legal system, and diminishes each of us.”
The lawsuit argues that Newsom abused his executive power by bypassing statutory requirements, such as providing notice to prosecutors and victims prior to acting. Challengers contend that the governor failed to conduct an individualized review of each case and that his blanket commutation disregards the will of California voters who have upheld the death penalty in statewide ballot measures.
The petition seeks an immediate stay preventing Newsom and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation from implementing the proposed commutations while the court considers the legal challenge. It also asks the justices to declare invalid any commutations issued without compliance with statutory procedures governing executive clemency.
“Only this Court can stop the Governor’s disregard of the law—his abuse of power,” the group wrote in its petition.
Newsom’s office maintains that he has constitutional authority to grant clemency on his own initiative without prior notice, a stance legal experts say will likely hold up. However, the commutations remain pending approval by the California Supreme Court for 382 inmates convicted of multiple felonies, while the remaining 166 with single felony convictions can be commuted unilaterally.
The coalition includes Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman, Sacramento County District Attorney Thien Ho, Riverside County District Attorney Michael Hestrin, San Diego County District Attorney Summer Stephan and Kern County District Attorney Cynthia Zimmer. Other participating prosecutors represent Amador, Butte, Calaveras, El Dorado, Fresno, Kings, Lake, Madera, Merced, Modoc, Monterey, Placer, San Bernardino, San Luis Obispo, San Mateo, Shasta, Solano, Stanislaus, Sutter, Tehama, Tulare, Ventura and Yuba counties.
Hochman stated: “We stand firmly with the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation in challenging this arbitrary commutation that sidelines victims’ families and disregards the will of California voters, juries and judges.”
In a separate filing, Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer submitted an amicus curiae brief challenging the governor’s proposed commutations for 382 death row inmates, arguing their felony convictions require additional review by the California Supreme Court. Spitzer said: “Our criminal justice system does not bend with the political winds, and one man—even if he is the governor—does not get to put his thumb on the scales of justice simply because he does not like the law.”
While Californians voted to uphold the death penalty in 2012 and 2016 ballot measures, no executions have occurred in California since 2006.
Among the most notorious convicted killers currently on California’s death row are Richard Allen Davis, who kidnapped and murdered 12-year-old Polly Klaas in 1993, and Randy Kraft, dubbed the “Scorecard Killer” for his list of 16 victims during the 1970s and ’80s.
Anne Marie Schubert, CJLF head and former Sacramento County District Attorney, stated: “The Governor’s clemency power does not authorize mass commutations that disregard constitutional safeguards, legally required procedures, or victims’ rights. By predetermining the outcome for every inmate on death row, the Governor has abandoned his responsibility to exercise meaningful discretion.”
Newsom’s commutations, if allowed, would represent the largest mass clemency in U.S. history and reduce the national death row population by nearly 30 percent, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.