In a 6-3 decision Tuesday morning, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Trump administration, holding that green card holders can be stripped of their status if they travel abroad while facing criminal charges involving moral turpitude. The Court determined that pending allegations are sufficient to subject them to removal proceedings.
The case, Blanche v. Lau, centered on Muk Choi Lau, a Chinese national who became a U.S. resident in 2007. He was arrested in 2012 and charged in New Jersey for allegedly selling $300,000 worth of knock-off shorts. While awaiting trial, Lau left the United States but upon his return he was deemed an “applicant for admission” by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which sought his removal.
The majority held that the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) does not require border officers to have clear and convincing evidence of a disqualifying offense at the moment a green card holder reenters the country. Instead, the government can satisfy the evidentiary burden during removal proceedings. The Court accepted the administration’s argument that requiring immediate proof at the border would be unworkable and that the statutory text (“has committed”) does not mandate a “conviction” or immediate proof before parole is granted.
This decision allows DHS to treat green card holders facing pending criminal charges as returning aliens awaiting inspection and eventual removal, rather than readmitting them as residents. The majority explained that removing a permanent resident on a charge of inadmissibility involves two steps: at step one, only the commission of the crime is required; at step two, conviction or admission is necessary to show inadmissibility.
Lau was correctly charged with inadmissibility. At step one, the government regarded him as an alien seeking admission because he had committed a crime involving moral turpitude prior to reentering. At step two, he was inadmissible and therefore removable due to his conviction on such a charge.
Three liberal justices dissented. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson wrote that the ruling effectively allows the government to “return an LPR [lawful permanent resident] to the status of ‘seeking an admission’ upon entry at the border, so long as the Government is able to show later that he was eventually convicted.” She argued this sequencing undermines the statutory scheme designed to protect lawful permanent residents.