Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial: Single Black Juror Voted for Guilt in 12-Member Jury

A lone black male juror in his 30s was the sole member of a Massachusetts jury who voted to find Lindsay Clancy guilty of murder, according to juror Paula Devlin’s revelation on “CBS Mornings” Friday.

The remaining jurors sided with Clancy’s defense team, which argued that she was not criminally responsible for strangling her three children—Cora, age 5; Dawson, age 3; and Callan, age 8 months—in the basement of their home in January 2023 due to postpartum psychosis.

The holdout juror aligned with prosecutors who maintained the killings were premeditated.

Devlin stated that the jury consisted of nine women and three men, with ages ranging from 22 to approximately 70. She noted there was only one person of color on the jury, with all others being white.

When asked by host Gayle King whether the “person of color” was a woman or man, Devlin confirmed it was a man.

King expressed surprise: “Is the holdout juror a person of—a black man?” she inquired.

Devlin responded: “A black man is the holdout juror?”

King added: “Well! I’ll have to sit with that for just a second.”

Devlin described the deliberations as tense, noting that the majority had leaned toward finding Clancy not criminally responsible from the outset, but the holdout juror refused to change his mind. She recounted that jurors spent several days attempting to persuade him, yet he “would not budge” and appeared to feel attacked when challenged.